|
Listen to article
|
Educational Mismatch – Disconnected Placements and Ineffective Skills Deployment
In a country where over 40% of graduates are underemployed or unemployed, the strategic deployment of skilled human capital should be a national imperative. Yet, the National Youth Service Corps (NYSC) program continues to operate as if educational alignment is a luxury, not a necessity. Instead of being a conduit for national development through well-matched service opportunities, NYSC has devolved into a bureaucratic exercise in random postings, scattering trained professionals across sectors and locations where their expertise is neither needed nor utilized. The result? A massive waste of intellectual capital, a demoralized youth population, and a policy failure that increasingly contradicts the very goals the program was designed to achieve.
Across the country, graduates trained in engineering are posted to teach in overcrowded classrooms, while education graduates are assigned to unrelated ministries or posted to firms that see them as little more than unpaid interns. This dislocation is not anecdotal—it is systemic. According to Chukwu and Okon (2021), only 36% of corps members reported being posted to institutions that aligned with their academic qualifications. For the rest, the disconnect was immediate and disorienting. The implications are profound: not only is the potential impact of corps members diminished, but the institutions that receive them are also denied access to relevant expertise.
The evidence of this mismatch is visible in educational and professional dissatisfaction among corps members. Bello et al. (2024) found that over 60% of real estate graduates surveyed during their NYSC year expressed frustration with the irrelevance of their service postings to their field of study. In many cases, the corps year becomes a hiatus from professional growth, a liminal space between education and career that delays, rather than accelerates, economic independence.
The implications of poor alignment are worsened by an equally weak skills deployment framework. While NYSC incorporates the Skill Acquisition and Entrepreneurship Development (SAED) program to compensate for placement gaps, the actual implementation is often inadequate. Muogbo, Eze, and Obananya (2021) criticized SAED for being too generic and lacking industry-specific relevance. Their study revealed that only 12% of participants found the training useful for post-service employment or entrepreneurship. Supporting this, Olofinyehun et al. (2023) observed that participants in structured apprenticeship programs outside NYSC fared significantly better in acquiring and applying practical skills.
These failures do not exist in a vacuum, they have ripple effects across sectors. Ogundipe and Farouk (2020) argue that the ineffectiveness of NYSC in skill deployment contributes to institutional fatigue in both public and private sectors. Organizations that once valued NYSC contributions now view corps members as unreliable and mismatched fillers. This erodes the credibility of the scheme and reduces the willingness of host organizations to invest in corps members’ training or mentorship.
Graduate perceptions of the NYSC are increasingly bleak. Yusuf (2023) described Nigeria’s youth service framework as an “educational mismatch turned national tragedy,” estimating that the loss of graduate labor productivity during service year results in an annual opportunity cost of approximately ₦280 billion. The calculation includes lost earnings, delayed entry into the labor market, and the depreciated relevance of academic training over time. In a developing economy, such waste is not just unfortunate, but it is unacceptable.
The consequences extend into graduates’ mental health and sense of national identity. Anongo et al. (2023), in a study on deployment experiences, found that 43% of respondents reported symptoms of “moral injury”—a psychological condition where individuals are compelled to act against their professional conscience or values. For many, being posted far from their specialization, often in contexts where they feel exploited or irrelevant, leads to disillusionment rather than patriotism.
Research shows that graduates from public institutions face job dissatisfaction due to skill mismatches. Akintayo and Odu (2022) argue that when young workers are not placed in roles that match their skills, they cannot contribute effectively to national development. Binuyo et al. (2020) highlight the need for integrating social innovation and skill acquisition into graduate programs to enhance national impact. The current NYSC structure does not fully utilize this potential.
Further, the program fails to account for evolving economic demands. Akere and Iwayemi (2023) emphasize the importance of entrepreneurship frameworks that align with 21st-century realities—technology, creative industries, renewable energy. Yet, NYSC’s placement and training models remain stuck in analog-era thinking. Even corps members with strong entrepreneurial interests are rarely provided the tools or networks to actualize them. Tibi (2023) noted that vocational counseling, when available, is often underfunded, inconsistent, and delivered by personnel untrained in modern labor trends.
The situation is even more absurd for graduates like those in theology or religious studies, who are systemically excluded from NYSC, yet trained in values and skills essential for community development. Ottuh (2021) frames this exclusion as discriminatory, undermining the goals of inclusivity and equal national service. In parallel, Ojapinwa (2020) highlighted how self-efficacy and entrepreneurial ambition are eroded when deployment environments do not affirm graduates’ training, causing a loss in confidence and delayed career pursuit.
Higher education policy analysts are sounding alarms. Aselebe (2022) emphasizes that Nigeria’s graduate unemployment crisis cannot be solved without aligning NYSC deployment with labor market realities. Idowu et al. (2020) point out that labor flexibility is essential for an adaptive economy, yet NYSC remains rigid, linear, and largely arbitrary in its design. Predictive models by Ajayi et al. (2022) even suggest that the NYSC’s operational tempo could be optimized through data-driven mobilization cycles—yet these innovations remain unexplored.
Read also: Beyond NYSC: Why Nigeria Must End Youth Service—Part 7
What is needed now is radical realignment. NYSC must shift from being a one-size-fits-all posting scheme to a dynamic, skills-matching national talent deployment system. Placements should be tied to academic credentials, labor market demand, and national development goals. Technology must be deployed to optimize placement, monitor satisfaction, and assess impact. Above all, graduates must be treated not as tools of political symbolism, but as strategic agents of national transformation.
Without such reform, the NYSC will remain a policy relic—well-intentioned but fundamentally broken. It will continue to waste what is arguably Nigeria’s most valuable resource: its educated youth. And in doing so, it will forfeit its claim to be a bridge to national progress.
References
Ajayi, O., Adeyemi, A. and Okonkwo, T., 2022. Predicting NYSC mobilization period using ARIMA model. Advances in Multidisciplinary and Scientific Research Journal. Available at: [Accessed 14 Apr. 2025].
Akere, O. and Iwayemi, O.D., 2023. Graduates’ entrepreneurship programme: A proper framework for national development. American Journal of Education and Technology. Available at: [Accessed 14 Apr. 2025].
Akintayo, S.O. and Odu, D., 2022. Employability skills and career mismatch in Nigeria’s public institutions. African Journal of Education Studies.
Anongo, F.S., Ibrahim, M. and Okoh, P., 2023. Deployment experiences and moral injury in Nigerian military veterans. Journal of Behavioral Health and Psychology.
Aselebe, K., 2022. Higher education and graduates’ unemployability in Nigeria: Policy implications. ECE Official Conference Proceedings.
Bello, N.A., Adekunle, S. and Ibrahim, T., 2024. Graduate competency and employer satisfaction: A concern for real estate graduates. Journal of African Real Estate Research.
Binuyo, A., Adeyemi, A. and Oladipo, K., 2020. Social innovation and skill acquisition among university graduates in Nigeria. International Journal of Innovative Research and Development.
Chukwu, C. and Okon, T., 2021. Job placement alignment and graduate job satisfaction in Nigeria. International Journal of Youth Policy.
Ehigbor, B.O., 2023. Assessment of practical teaching difficulties among NYSC members serving as ad-hoc teachers. International Journal of Education, Humanities and Social Science (IJEHSS).
Idowu, T., Adewale, M. and Ogunleye, S., 2020. Flexibility of work and labour deployment in the Nigerian labour market. Al Tijarah.
Muogbo, U.S., Eze, S.U. and Obananya, C.G., 2021. Skill acquisition as tool for solving youth restiveness and unemployment in Nigeria: The role of NYSC. International Journal of Multidisciplinary Educational Research.
Ogundipe, M. and Farouk, B., 2020. An analysis of NYSC’s effectiveness in skill deployment. Nigerian Educational Review.
Ojapinwa, A., 2020. Effects of self-efficacy on self-employment intention of recent graduates. Lagos Journal of Educational Research and Human Resource Management (LJERHRM), 2, pp.158–171.
Olofinyehun, A., Adeyeye, J., Egbetokun, A., Olomu, M., Oluwadare, J., Sanni, M. and Orisadare, M., 2023. Pooled longitudinal dataset on the assessment of an apprenticeship-based entrepreneurship intervention in Nigeria. Research Data Journal for the Humanities and Social Sciences. Available at: [Accessed 14 Apr. 2025].
Oboreh, J. and Emmanuel, A., 2020. Effect of creativity on human capital development of graduate entrepreneurs. Academy of Entrepreneurship Journal, 26.
Ottuh, J.A., 2021. Exclusion of theological graduates from NYSC. Societies Journal, 1(2).
Tibi, E., 2023. Vocational interest, skills, and counselling among unemployed graduates in Delta State. International Research Journal of Management, IT and Social Sciences (IRJMIS).
Yusuf, L.A., 2023. Unused potential: Educational mismatch and national loss. Journal of Human Capital Development Studies.
